|Water-Related Issues Affecting Conventional Oil and Gas Recovery and Potential Oil Shale Development in the Uinta Basin, Utah
||Last Reviewed 5/15/2012
The goal of this project is to overcome existing water-related environmental barriers to possible oil shale development in the Uinta Basin, Utah. Data collected from this study will help alleviate problems associated with disposal of produced saline water, which is a by-product of methods used to facilitate conventional hydrocarbon production.
Utah Geological Survey, Salt Lake City, Utah, 84114
- Uinta Basin Petroleum Companies: Questar, Anadarko, Newfield, Enduring Resources, Bill Barrett, Berry Petroleum, EOG Resources, FIML, Wind River Resources, Devon, Rosewood, Flying J, Gasco, Mustang Fuel, Forest, Royale, BT Operating, Elk Resources, McElvain, Summit Operating, Whiting Petroleum, Pendragon, Oil Shale Exploration Company
- Utah Division of Oil, Gas, and Mining
- U.S. Bureau of Land Management
- U.S. Geological Survey
- UI.S. Environmental Protection Agency – Region 8
Saline water disposal is the single most pressing issue with regard to increasing petroleum and natural gas production in the Uinta Basin in Utah. Conventional oil fields in the basin provide 69% of Utah’s total crude oil production and 71% of Utah’s total natural gas, the latter of which has increased 60% in the last 10 years (Utah Division of Oil, Gas and Mining, 2009). As petroleum production increases, so does saline water production, increasing the need for economic and environmentally responsible disposal plans. Current water disposal wells are near capacity and permitting for new wells is being delayed because of a lack of technical data regarding potential impacts to disposal aquifers and questions concerning contamination of fresh water sources. Many Uinta Basin operators claim that petroleum and natural gas production cannot reach its full potential until a suitable long-term, saline water disposal solution is found.
Currently, the agencies responsible for regulating the disposal of produced water use 20-year-old data amassed in a publication entitled “Base of Moderately Saline Ground Water in the Uinta Basin, Utah” to determine zones suitable for water disposal (Howells and others, 1987). This hard copy publication provides a paper map showing the depth of the transition between moderately saline and very saline water (10,000 mg/L). It is believed that saline water can be injected below this depth without damage to overlying fresh-water aquifers. Several oil and gas operators working in the basin believe this dated study requires substantial revision.
Figure 1. Bird’s-nest aquifer as exposed in outcrop, Evacuation Creek, Uintah County, Utah. This aquifer lies several hundred feet above the richest oil shale unit.
Eastern Uinta Basin gas producers claim that one of the only aquifers suitable for large volume saline water disposal is the Birds Nest aquifer located in the Parachute Creek Member of the Green River Formation (Figure 1). After an extensive literature search, it was determined that the Birds Nest aquifer is poorly understood and further study is necessary before large-scale saline water disposal can commence. The Birds Nest aquifer is typically several hundred feet above the richest oil shale interval called the Mahogany zone. A significant concern is that saline water disposal into the Birds Nest by conventional gas producers may hinder oil shale development by creating unforeseen economic and technical hurdles. In many areas containing rich oil shale deposits, the Birds Nest contains fresh to slightly saline water (Holmes and Kimball, 1987) (Figure 2). By increasing saline water discharge into the aquifer, the Birds Nest water quality could degrade, creating additional water disposal problems for oil shale development companies.
In addition to the water-related problems mentioned above, there is a regulatory need for baseline water quality and quantity data covering proposed oil shale development lands (Figure 2). Water-quality degradation could result from new oil shale developments via mining and surface retort or in situ processes. An up-to-date Geographic Information System (GIS) database would provide the baseline water information needed to understand potential impacts of future oil shale development.
Figure 2. Map showing proposed study area, Uinta Basin, Utah. Note the
prime oil shale area overlaps with several natural gas fields.
Each successful part of this multi-faceted study will provide the information needed to achieve two goals: (1) alleviation of problems associated with produced saline water usage as a means to facilitate increased conventional hydrocarbon production, and (2) resolving environmental barriers to possible oil shale development.
By utilizing the newly developed GIS maps, regulators and oil and natural gas operators can make informed saline water disposal management decisions and protect freshwater resources. If new, appropriate, saline water disposal intervals can be identified that are similar to the Birds Nest aquifer, oil and natural gas production can continue to increase, supplying the nation’s growing demand with safe, convenient, domestic resources. Additionally, environmentally sound water management solutions for a future oil shale industry can be developed once the sensitivities of alluvial and bedrock aquifers within potential oil shale development regions are understood.
- Completed a preliminary map of the base of the moderately saline aquifer (BMSA)
- Completed interpretation of digital geophysical logs from 258 wells throughout the Uinta Basin, picking the BMSA in each well
- Completed detailed descriptions of all core from the Birds Nest aquifer.
- Researchers finished examining core containing the Birds Nest zone, which provides crucial ground truth to interpret the geophysical logs from wells lacking core.
- Completed preliminary maps displaying the areal extent and thickness of the Birds Nest aquifer. The Birds Nest zone in over 250 wells has been mapped on the aquifer’s areal extent in central Uintah County. This first-of-its-kind map will greatly aid in determining potential Birds Nest aquifer saline water disposal areas.
- Prepared an article for Survey Notes summarizing project goals and results (Survey Notes is a UGS magazine published three times a year)
- Presented posters outlining the project at the American Association of Petroleum Geologists (AAPG) Annual meeting in June 2009, April 2010, and April 2011.
- Created a project website: http://geology.utah.gov/ [external site].
- Completed a Water Quality Assurance Plan and initiated water sample collection and analysis.
- Collected over 2300 water chemistry samples for analyses from over 1300 wells in the Uinta Basin.
- Developed improved techniques for determining the BMSA from geophysical logs.
- Created an extensive (>350 wells) database of oil shale formation tops.
- Determined that the most accurate method for characterizing the Birds Nest aquifer is by detailed rock core analysis.
- Collected three rounds of water samples from wells, springs, and rivers in central Uinta County. The first two sets of samples have been analyzed for total dissolved solids and other chemical constituents.
- Collected hundreds of downhole water samples and analyzed their chemistry; collected hundreds of digitized log files to aid in determining the BMSA.
Current Status (May 2012)
The project is completed. The final report is available below under "Additional Information".
Project Start: October 1, 2008
Project End: April 30, 2012
DOE Contribution: $688,222
Performer Contribution: $172,056
NETL –Skip Pratt (email@example.com or 304-285-4396)
Utah Geological Survey – Michael Vanden Berg (firstname.lastname@example.org or 801-538-5419)
Final Project Report [PDF-99.3MB]
Utah Geological Survey project website [external site]
Technology Status Assessment [PDF-126KB]