|Field Demonstration of Carbon Dioxide Miscible Flooding in the Lansing Kansas City Formation, Central Kansas/Class Revisit
The goal of the project is to determine the economic and technical feasibility of using CO2 miscible flooding to recover residual and bypassed oil in a Lansing Kansas City formation oilfield in central Kansas.
Tertiary Oil Recovery Project (TORP), University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS
Kansas Geological Survey, Lawrence, KS
Kinder-Morgan CO2, Houston, TX
Murfin Drilling Company, Wichita, KS
White Eagle Resources, Lafayette, CO
John O. Farmer, Inc, Russell, KS
ICM, Inc., Colwich, KS
Kansas Dept. of Commerce, Topeka, KS
The project involves injecting CO2 from an ethanol plant into the Lansing Kansas City C formation in the Hall Gurney field near Russell, KS. The oil reservoir is a thin, oomoldic carbonate zone located at a depth of about 2900 feet. The reservoir zone was water flooded previously and abandoned in about 1990. The pilot consists of one CO2 injection well and two production wells on about 10 acre spacing. Water injection wells were used to confine the CO2 to the pilot area.
The project was carried out in three phases: Phase 1 – Reservoir characterization and economic analysis, Phase 2 – Implementation, and Phase 3 – Post CO2 flood monitoring. Phase 1 began on March 8, 2000, and was completed on March 6, 2004. Phase 2 began on March 7, 2004, and was completed on December 31, 2008. Phase 3 began on January 1, 2009, and will be completed on March 7, 2010.
Continuous injection of CO2 into the Lansing Kansas City C formation in Hall Gurney field near Russell, KS began on December 2, 2003. CO2 was trucked from the ethanol plant operated by U.S. Energy Partners by EPCO, where it was unloaded into a portable storage tank on the lease. CO2 was injected as a compressed fluid using an injection skid provided by FLOCO2. By the end of June 2005, about 16.92 million pounds of CO2 had been injected. The average rate of CO2 injection from January through June 2005 was about 245 MCFD. CO2 injection was converted to water injection on June 21, 2005, in an effort to reduce operating costs to a breakeven level with the expectation that sufficient CO2 was injected to displace the oil bank to the production wells by water injection. The amount of CO2 produced was about 5 percent of the injected CO2.
Oil production from the pilot lease (7778 bbl) was less than anticipated and was slower to build than expected. In August 2006, wells on the adjacent leases (Colliver A and Graham) north of the pilot area were opened in the C zone and have produced substantial amounts of oil that has been attributed to the CO2 flood. As of May 31, 2009, about 16,193 bbl of incremental oil were estimated to have been produced from these wells since the beginning of the CO2 project. Incremental oil production from the CO2 pilot area and the Graham and Colliver A leases attributed to CO2 injection was about 23,971 bbl which is equivalent to a gross CO2 ratio of 5.7 MCF/bbl.
The CO2 miscible flood demonstration project represents the first use of CO2 for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) in Kansas. The Hall-Gurney field, the largest Lansing Kansas City oilfield in Kansas, is one of several CO2 flood candidate fields in central Kansas. There are no miscible CO2 floods in Kansas, due primarily to the distance from CO2 sources.
The project is a unique, scalable model for linked energy systems. Waste heat from a municipal 15-megawatt gas-fired turbine electric power generator provides heat inputs for a 25 million gallon per year ethanol plant. CO2, a fermentation byproduct of ethanol production, will be utilized by the CO2 miscible flood project in the Hall-Gurney field. The full CO2 stream from the ethanol plant could supply a small oilfield capable of producing five million barrels of oil and sequestering 1.5 million tons of CO2 over 20 years.
CO2 flooding demonstrated in this project has the potential to prevent up to 6,000 mature oilfields in Kansas from being abandoned and result in the recovery of more than 250-500 million barrels of incremental oil, equivalent to 5-10 years of additional Kansas production. The project’s original objective, to demonstrate to Kansas independents the feasibility of CO2 flooding and to find a viable supply of CO2, is being met with a joint industry venture that could also benefit agriculture, ethanol production, and electric power generation, as well as independent oil producers.
Phase 1: Reservoir characterization and economic analysis(March 8, 2000-March 6, 2004)
Phase 1 involved acquisition and consolidation of data into a web-based accessible database, and geologic, petro physical, and engineering reservoir characterization at the proposed demonstration site to understand the reservoir system and economics of the project. Descriptive and numerical models of the reservoir were developed and used in a reservoir simulator to predict oil recovery and the optimum location for a new injector well. Evaluation of the economics of CO2 flooding was based on improved reservoir characterization, advanced flow simulation, and engineering analyses. Test wells were remediated and the pilot area was repressurized with water injection to evaluate inter-well properties. CO2 injectivity tests were conducted to verify the injection rate into CO2 I-1 and evaluate premature breakthrough.
Phase 2: Implement CO2 Flood (March 7,2004-December 31, 2008)
Phase 2 activities covered full-scale implementation of the CO2 pilot flood. The pilot carbon dioxide miscible flood was initiated in the Lansing Kansas City C formation in the Hall Gurney Field, Russell County, Kansas. The reservoir zone is an oomoldic carbonate located at a depth of about 2900 feet. The pilot consists of one carbon dioxide injection well and three production wells. Continuous carbon dioxide injection began on December 2, 2003. Field personnel quickly picked up operating experience with carbon dioxide injection and management of production wells, and gained sufficient experience to manage a field-scale flood. Operating costs were assessed for both injection of carbon dioxide and production of oil, water, and carbon dioxide. Minimum miscibility pressure (p>1250 psi) was maintained in the pilot area with the assistance of water confinement wells. The switch to water injection after injection of 16.19MM lb (138.05MMCF) of CO2 was trouble-free. About 95% of injected CO2 remained in the reservoir as of June 2005. Oil displacement continued as the water displaced CO2into new areas of the reservoir. By the end of June 2005, 16.19 MM lb of carbon dioxide was injected into the pilot area. Injection was converted to water on June 21, 2005, to reduce operating costs to a breakeven level with the expectation that sufficient carbon dioxide was injected to displace the oil bank to the production wells by water injection. In August 2006, it was discovered that a production increase from the Colliver A Lease located north of the pilot lease was in response to CO2 injection in the pilot lease. There is a northwesterly directional permeability trend toward the pilot region. The pilot area is more heterogeneous than represented in the reservoir model. The amount of reservoir heterogeneity was not predictable from available reservoir data and it was not possible to predict with certainty which wells would produce incremental oil. As of May 31, 2009, incremental oil produced from the pilot lease and leases north of the pilot lease was 23,971 bbl or 5.7 MMF/bbl. A preliminary geologic model was developed that is consistent with the heterogeneity determined from analysis of production data.
Phase 3: Post CO2 Flood Monitoring-(January 1, 2009-March 7, 2010)
By March 7, 2010, 8,736 bbl of oil were produced from the pilot. Production from wells to the northwest of the pilot region indicates that oil displaced from carbon dioxide injection was produced from Colliver A7, Colliver A3, Colliver A14 and Graham A4 located on adjacent leases. About 19,166 bbl of incremental oil were estimated to have been produced from these wells as of March 7, 2010. There is evidence of a directional permeability trend toward the northwest through the pilot region. The majority of the injected carbon dioxide remains in the pilot region, which has been maintained at a pressure at or above the minimum miscibility pressure. Estimated oil recovery attributed to the CO2 flood is 27,902 bbl, which is equivalent to a gross CO2 utilization of 4.8 MCF/bbl. The pilot project is not economic.
Phase 3 activities involve monitoring and evaluating the CO2 pilot flood and preparing a final report. The report has been submitted and accepted by DOE.
Current Status (July 2010)
The project was completed on March 7, 2010. The final report is available below under "Publications".
The 70-acre lease containing the 10 acre CO2 pilot is in Hall-Gurney oilfield near Russell, KS.
Project Start: March 8, 2000
Project End: March 7, 2010
Anticipated DOE Contribution: $1,760,000
Performer Contribution: $2,820,000 (62 percent of total)
NETL – Chandra Nautiyal (email@example.com or 281-494-2488)
University of Kansas - Paul Willhite (firstname.lastname@example.org or 785-864-2906)
Final Project Report [PDF-7.99MB] March, 2000 - March, 2010
Other reports and presentations are available at http:/www.torp.ku.edu [external site].
The Russell Kansas CO2 Pilot - An Operator's Perspective by Tom Nichols, Murfin Drilling Company, for Mid-year KIOGA, April 21, 2005
Field Demonstration of CO2 Miscible Flooding in the Lansing-Kansas City Formation, Central Kansas by G. Paul Willhite to 16th Oil Recovery Conference, Wichita, KS, April 7, 2005
An Overview of the Carbon Dioxide Pilot Test in the Hall Gurney Field in Russell County, Kansas by G. Paul Willhite, Tertiary Oil Recovery Project, University of Kansas, December 2004
Reducing Risk in the Implementation of the CO2 Pilot Test in the Hall-Gurney Russell County, Kansas by G. Paul Willhite, Tertiary Oil Recovery Project, Department of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering, University of Kansas, March 13, 2003
Overview - Carbon Dioxide Pilot Test in the Hall Gurney Field in Russell County, Kansas by G. Paul Willhite, Tertiary Oil Recovery Project, Department of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering, University of Kansas, March 12, 2003
Field Demonstration of CO2 Miscible Flooding in the L-KC, Central Kansas Alan P. Byrnes to the Department of Energy, Tulsa, Oklahoma April 13, 2001
Update: Field Demonstration of CO2 Miscible Flooding in the L-KC, Central Kansas Martin K. Dubois to the Kansas Geological Society, Wichita, Kansas March 1, 2001
Field Demonstration of Carbon Dioxide Miscible Flooding in the Lansing-Kansas City Formation, Central Kansas Richard Pancake & Alan P. Byrnes to the Sixth Annual CO2 Conference, Midland, Texas December 6, 2000
CO2 storage tank and injection skid.
Hall-Gurney field and nearby ethanol plant, Russell, KS.